Thursday, May 20, 2010
The Virginian-You
Words Jesse Scaccia
Thursday, May 20th, 2010 at 8:48 am
I’ve lived in my current apartment for almost nine months, but it was only last night that I made it to my first neighborhood association meeting.
It turns out one of my neighbors is none other than Maurice Jones, publisher of the Virginian-Pilot.
Small world, eh?

Not everyone in my neighborhood has that haircut...
Jones spoke candidly and took questions for about 45 minutes in front of the Freemason Street Area Association. I had met Jones briefly before at a high school journalism conference, but I had never heard him speak before. My gut reaction: The Pilot is in the hands of a man who is sharp, confident, and honest with himself enough to acknowledge that newspapers can no longer stand on their own, but need to be supported by auxiliary businesses.
He’s also charming, quick with a joke, and diffused the audience’s more aggressive questions with a particular aplomb. I could be very wrong–I’m still relatively new around here–but this region seems lucky to have him as our paper’s publisher.
Following are some of the more interesting things Jones said at the meeting last night. [Warning: this is an unabashed notebook dump.] Let me start with some caveats: this was not a press conference, but a casual neighborhood meeting, so I wouldn’t hold Jones to exact numbers. And even though when I asked a question Jones knew who I was, there’s a chance he didn’t realize a reporter was there before that. Does this matter? Probably not, but I’m telling you anyway.
What’s written is a quote from Jones; what’s in parentheses are my notes/clarifications.
Health of The Pilot
The newspaper business is going through a transformation. The Pilot is healthy. We’re in a very good place.
Subscribers are 15-20% of a typical newspaper’s revenue. One of the challenges we’ve had to confront is what happens when 80% hits recession? You’ve got to cut back on your expenses.
(According to Jones, during his tenure, they’ve went from 1,300 to 1,000 jobs.)
Alternate revenue sources // Business models

Jones (Photo | hamptonroads.com)
We’ve got Pilot Direct: You would call it junk mail. We have the ability to direct mail to your home.
We deliver other newspapers’ papers to your home.
When I got here, we hadn’t raised subscription prices since 1999. I know no other business that can keep prices stable for seven years.
The theory is, keep the prices low on papers, so you get a lot of readers, to keep the advertisers.
In the future, few papers will rely on subscribers.
We’re not a newspaper company. We’re a media company that needs to diversify.
The paper thrown on your porch will be the Daily James, or the Daily Admiral. We’ll give each one of us our own newspaper. I envision everybody getting the same core, the rest will be customized.
We’ve talked about having a different front page for delivery and newsstand, but I’m afraid of what we might get. Crime and entertainment are what pulls people in.
(On alternative revenue sources:) You’ll see stickers. Ads on the front page, ads inside of editorial. That pays the bills, and we’ve got to find a way to do that in a way that is tasteful and non-offensive to our readers. Competition is so intense. (If they don’t do things like this) we’ll lose the business, and if we lose the business we won’t be able to keep the paper.
Our niche business is 30% and growing. Everything but the paper amounts to 40% of our business.When I got here in 2005, 93% of profit was in The Pilot itself.
It’s like the Cleveland Cavaliers. When Lebron has a bad game, do you have a supporting cast that’s as talented so you won’t lose?
Online // Readership // Reader habits
Every Sunday, 500,000 people read The Pilot. The biggest day of the year for TV is the Super Bowl. There are fewer people who watch the Super Bowl in this market than read The Pilot on Sunday.
Not true that young folks don’t want to read print either.
What the web offers is to search for what you want, get what you want, and get out of there.
The web leads to a less informed citizenry.
We can track your every move online. We’re gonna have to figure out that information for the print edition as well.
Perception of their coverage
People have stopped talking to us. We’re only as good as our sources.
(On why other school districts have received less intense coverage than Norfolk:) My guess is we don’t have the same sources in other districts.
There’s no joy in this stuff, knowing it could be harmful to the region. Our job is to be brutally honest about the facts.
We consider ourselves the newspaper of record for South Hampton Roads. We’ll always favor local stories over national. But if The Pope dies, The Pope goes on the front page.
Advertisers
The biggest advertisers used to be employers looking for employees. Now, it is groceries, media, auto, and real estate.
Advertisers blame newspapers for everything. Everybody is stressed. I have more calls from advertisers saying they’re pulling out of the paper because of that editorial than ever before.
(When I asked if he feels increased pressure to blur the line between editorial and advertising, he said:) I get the pressure, more than ever, but I don’t feel it. I do get more calls.
The moment I look like I can be bought is the moment I lose you all.
Editor’s Note: In the original version of this story Jones was quoted as giving an absurdly wrong average readership time statistic. Upon receiving more accurate information from Pilot editors, the line has been deleted altogether.
COMMENTS
Facebook comments:
ABOUT THE WRITER
Jesse is the editor in chief of AltDaily, and he's going to take this bio seriously, but not so seriously that he's going to continue in the third person. I've been involved with a bunch of local projects and civic groups in various roles, including: Hampton Roads, The Canvas; Art | Everywhere, Street Performance in Norfolk; Survive Norfolk; Hampton Roads Pride/Out in the Park; Bike Norfolk; re:Vision Norfolk, and such.
I originally came to Norfolk as a Perry Morgan fellow in ODU's creative writing program. Before that I bummed around quite a bit, writing stacks of books that never got published, hitchhiking, couchsurfing, riding the Greyhound up down and back across this country. Some of my favorite jobs and volunteer gigs have included working on organic farms in Ireland; being first mate on an old sail boat in Holland; working at a long-term home for young men in South Africa; being a journalist and high school teacher in New York and California; washing dishes in Yosemite National Park; teaching English in DC and swimming in Florida; and interning at ESPN in Bristol, which was much less cool that you'd want it to be. My career highlights have been having three of my op-eds run in the New York Times, and being the executive producer of a six-part docu-drama on BET. Because school is cool I have three master's degrees (ODU for MFA, NYU for magazine journalism, University of Connecticut for secondary English education). I live in Norfolk because I believe in its potential. Email your ideas or nicely couched criticism to jesse@altdaily.com.
Other posts by Jesse Scaccia.
Other posts by Jesse Scaccia.










Great piece, Jesse! Thanks for sharing.
My reaction to some of Mr. Jones’ comments:
> “The paper thrown on your porch will be the Daily James, or the Daily Admiral. We’ll give each one of us our own newspaper. I envision everybody getting the same core, the rest will be customized.”
I would love this. I skim the entire paper every day, but the only section I really care about is Hampton Roads — and the letters on the editorial page. Give me the local news, and give me my neighbors’ opinions. I can get everything else somewhere else.
> “Crime and entertainment are what pulls people in.”
Interesting, given The Pilot’s entertainment coverage is average at best. The Daily Break isn’t what it used to be, and Pulse doesn’t come close to replacing what we lost when he pulled the plug on PortFolio.
> “The web leads to a less informed citizenry.”
This doesn’t make sense to me at all. Can you elaborate on this comment, Jesse?
> “People have stopped talking to us. We’re only as good as our sources.”
Not good.
Thanks, Jim.
He said the web leads to a less informed citizenry in relation to the fact that people spend so much less time reading the paper online.
And no, not good at all. But their reporters work hard. I have faith in them.
Speaking as a “focus group of one,” I get very little news from The Pilot’s Web site. The value — for me, anyway — is the dialogue that takes place in the comments section after most articles. I will read a piece in the print edition and go online to see what other people are saying about the subject. I’d say that leads to a more informed citizenry.
Eh, I visit PilotOnline a lot. Way more than 45 seconds, and more than once a day. I go to leave my comments on their stories. If there wasn’t a comment box, I wouldn’t visit as often.
I post on every housing and real estate related thread. Back when the market was on fire and the Virginia Pilot was fanning the flames, I would post links to the good information I got from web sites regarding what was going to happen. I think the Pilot did a dis-service to the young people by acting as a shill on behalf of their real estate advertisers. I’ll never forget the stories about all the young vibrant people buying their condos in Granby Tower, of course, all of the ones mentioned worked pedaling mortgages (Geez what happens to those jobs when the mania ends?) Yes, I know doctors and other wealthy people bought them to flip, and perhaps someone bought one to live in.
I don’t really see where the Pilot has innovated much. I’m not even sure what the 1,000 remaining employees do. Does it really take 1000 people to write the small amount of content you see?
And the FSAA (or whatever the neighborhood association is) picture is epic.
Ethan, you are both right, & missed the point of what Mr. Jones had to say about the innovation of the Pilot.
It does not take 1000 people to run The Virginian-Pilot. But The Pilot is more than just the daily newspaper. Virginian-Pilot Media Companies prints a majority of the news & information in Hampton Roads, including – The Flagship, Apartment Book, Tidewater Parent, VOW Bride, Auto Guide, Inside Business, & more. There are websites & events associated with all of the publications & businesses that make up VPMC. Not to mention the behind-the-scenes people who are designing, printing & delivering all of those publications.
The innovation piece can be found not only in print with updated layout & editorial content, but online as well. http://www.MyTidewaterMoms.com is a social networking group for busy moms, Pilot Direct allows advertisers to reach customers mailboxes, Precision Ads puts advertisers on the front page.
There’s a reason VPMC is still healthy when other print news companies are foundering. It’s people & innovation.
PS – Portfolio lives online – http://www.PortfolioWeekly.com